The source
The exact words
“So Greek mathematics is ‘permanent’, more permanent even than Greek literature. Archimedes will be remembered when Aeschylus is forgotten, because languages die and mathematical ideas do not. ‘Immortality’ may be a silly word, but probably a mathematician has the best chance of whatever it may mean.”
A Mathematician's Apology. Section 8. Cambridge University Press, 1940.
The quote is accurate. It is the end of section 8, where Hardy argues that curiosity, professional pride and ambition drive research, and that mathematics satisfies ambition best because it lasts longest.
The story
Why Hardy said it
Hardy wrote A Mathematician's Apology in 1940, at 63, after a heart attack had left him convinced that his creative years were over. The book opens with that melancholy: a working mathematician should be doing mathematics, not writing about it. What follows is a defence of a life spent on pure mathematics, written by someone who thought he could no longer add to it.
In section 8 he asks why anyone does research at all. Not to benefit humanity, he says, whatever scientists claim. The real motives are curiosity, pride in good work and ambition, and mathematics rewards all three, ambition most of all, because nothing a person makes lasts longer. Babylon's kings are empty names, but its base 60 still measures our hours and angles. The Greeks were the first mathematicians who are still real to us; as Littlewood told him, they are not clever schoolboys but “Fellows of another college”.
So, the line on the collage: Archimedes will outlast Aeschylus. The comparison is pointed, because Hardy had a classical education at Winchester and loved Greek. Aeschylus wrote seventy to ninety plays and seven survive, and they need translators to reach us at all. A proof needs none. Archimedes' result that a sphere has two thirds the volume and surface of the cylinder around it is as true and as readable today as in Syracuse. He was so proud of it that he asked for a sphere in a cylinder on his tomb, and that is how Cicero found the overgrown grave in 75 BC.
Hardy then deflates himself at once. Immortality is often ridiculous, he adds, and mathematics has its jokes too: Farey is remembered for a theorem that Haros had already proved fourteen years earlier. The whole argument is in A Mathematician's Apology, and the same faith in mathematical beauty runs through Poincaré on delight in beauty and Russell on mathematics' supreme beauty.
Mathematician
Who was G. H. Hardy?
- Born
- 7 February 1877, Cranleigh
- Died
- 1 December 1947, Cambridge
- Known for
- Analysis, number theory, Ramanujan
- Wrote it
- A Mathematician's Apology, 1940
Godfrey Harold Hardy was born in Cranleigh, Surrey, the son of two teachers. He went from Winchester to Trinity College, Cambridge, and spent his life between Cambridge and Oxford, as Savilian Professor at Oxford from 1919 and Sadleirian Professor at Cambridge from 1931.
His thirty-five-year collaboration with J. E. Littlewood reshaped analysis and number theory. In 1913 he read a letter full of strange formulas from a clerk in Madras, recognised Srinivasa Ramanujan's genius and brought him to Cambridge, which he later called the one romantic incident in his life. His textbook A Course of Pure Mathematics taught generations of students, and it is still on the Cambridge reading list. He loved cricket, distrusted mirrors and photographs, and was proud that his work had no use. He died in Cambridge in December 1947.
Read next
Questions
About this quote
Where did Hardy say “Archimedes will be remembered when Aeschylus is forgotten”?
In section 8 of A Mathematician's Apology, published by Cambridge University Press in 1940.
Who were Archimedes and Aeschylus?
Archimedes (about 287–212 BC) was the greatest mathematician of antiquity, from Syracuse in Sicily. Aeschylus (about 525–456 BC) was the first of the great Athenian tragedians, the author of the Oresteia.
What did Hardy mean?
That literature lives in a language and fades as the language dies, while a mathematical idea means the same thing in every language and every century. So a mathematician, he argued, has the best chance of anything like immortality.
What comes right before the quote?
“So Greek mathematics is ‘permanent’, more permanent even than Greek literature.” Just before that, Hardy quotes Littlewood calling the Greek mathematicians “Fellows of another college”.





