The source
The exact words
“It’s like asking why Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony is beautiful. If you don’t see why, someone can’t tell you. I know numbers are beautiful. If they aren’t beautiful, nothing is.”
Paul Hoffman, “The Man Who Loves Only Numbers”. The Atlantic Monthly, November 1987. Repeated in Hoffman's book The Man Who Loved Only Numbers (Hyperion, 1998).
Erdős said this to the writer Paul Hoffman. The opening question is not his: in the article Hoffman sets it up by noting that beauty and insight are words Erdős and his colleagues use freely but find hard to explain. Later quotation collections turned that into “Why are numbers beautiful?” and put it in Erdős's mouth.
The story
Why Erdős said it
In 1986 Paul Hoffman, a young science writer, set out to profile Erdős for The Atlantic, which meant trying to keep up with him. Erdős was 73 and had no home, no job and no possessions beyond a suitcase or two. He travelled from one mathematician's house to the next, announcing “My brain is open”, working on problems for a few days and moving on, and by then he had written more papers with more collaborators than anyone in history.
The line came up over a proof Erdős did not like. In 1976 Kenneth Appel and Wolfgang Haken had settled the four-color problem, showing that any map can be colored with four colors so that no neighbours match, by having computers check more than 1,500 configurations in over a thousand hours of machine time. Erdős told Hoffman he assumed the proof was true. “However, it's not beautiful,” he said; he wanted a proof that showed why four colors are enough.
Beauty and insight, Hoffman wrote, are words that Erdős and his colleagues use freely but have difficulty explaining. Erdős answered with the comparison on the collage: it is like asking why Beethoven's Ninth is beautiful. If you don't see it, no one can tell you. That is as close as he came to defining it, but he had an image for it. God, whom he called the Supreme Fascist, keeps a Book with the perfect proof of every theorem, and a mathematician's highest compliment was “That's straight from the Book.” The proof on the collage's open page, that 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 is half of a 4 by 5 rectangle, is the kind he meant.
He was in good company. Hardy had written that mathematical ideas outlast everything else and that beauty is the first test, and Russell and Dirac said much the same. To see Erdős himself, N Is a Number, the 1993 documentary about him, is on our list of beautiful math documentaries.
Mathematician
Who was Paul Erdős?
- Born
- 26 March 1913, Budapest
- Died
- 20 September 1996, Warsaw
- Known for
- Number theory, combinatorics, random graphs
- Said it
- To Paul Hoffman, The Atlantic, 1987
Paul Erdős was born in Budapest in 1913 to two mathematics teachers. At 19 he published a new, elementary proof that there is always a prime between any number and its double, and he went on to shape number theory, combinatorics, graph theory and probability, founding the probabilistic method and, with Alfréd Rényi, the theory of random graphs.
He wrote about 1,500 papers with more than 500 co-authors, which gave rise to the Erdős number, a mathematician's distance from him in the chain of collaboration. He called children epsilons, offered cash prizes for problems he could not solve, and gave most of his own prize money away. In 1998, two years after his death, Martin Aigner and Günter Ziegler published Proofs from THE BOOK in his memory. He died in Warsaw in September 1996, at a conference, at 83.
Read next
Questions
About this quote
Where did Erdős say numbers are beautiful like Beethoven's Ninth?
In conversation with Paul Hoffman, who quoted him in “The Man Who Loves Only Numbers”, The Atlantic Monthly, November 1987, and again in his 1998 biography The Man Who Loved Only Numbers.
Did Erdős ask “Why are numbers beautiful?”
Not in the original. The question was implied by Hoffman's sentence before the quote; quotation collections later added it as Erdős's own opening line.
What prompted the remark?
The computer-assisted proof of the four-color theorem by Appel and Haken (1976). Erdős accepted it as true but said it was not beautiful, because it did not give insight into why four colors suffice.
What is “The Book” Erdős talked about?
His imaginary book, kept by God, containing the most elegant proof of every theorem. He said you don't have to believe in God, but you should believe in The Book.





