The source
The exact words
“Thos Edison once said that 75% of the world's failures wouldn't have failed at all if they'd only kept at what they were trying to do. “Our greatest weakness,” he said, “lies in giving up. The most certain way to succeed is always to try just one more time.””
Robert Mines, “Don't Give Up!”, Mechanix Illustrated. June 1958, credited to Edison without a source. Reprinted in Quote magazine, 13 July 1958, and in newspapers the same summer. No earlier printing is known.
This is the earliest known printing, from Robert Mines's article “Don't Give Up!” in Mechanix Illustrated, June 1958, as reprinted in Quote magazine that July. Mines gives no source, and Edison had died in 1931. No one has found the words in anything printed during his lifetime.
The story
Where the line really comes from
The habit the line describes was real. In the autumn of 1879, at his laboratory in Menlo Park, New Jersey, Edison and his team were hunting for a filament that would glow inside a vacuum bulb without burning out. They carbonized and tested cotton thread, paper, cardboard, fishing line and wood shavings, and logged the failures in notebook after notebook. A lamp with a carbonized cotton thread burned for about thirteen hours that October, and within a year carbonized bamboo was lasting more than a thousand. Edison later sent men around the world to collect thousands of plant fibres in search of something better.
The sentence on the collage, though, has no source in Edison's lifetime. Its earliest known appearance is an article called “Don't Give Up!” by Robert Mines in the June 1958 issue of Mechanix Illustrated, a popular how-to magazine, published 27 years after Edison's death. Mines writes that Edison once said 75 per cent of the world's failures would not have failed if they had only kept at it, and then quotes him, with no date, place or reference. Quote magazine reprinted the paragraph that July, newspapers picked it up, and by the 1960s it was in school yearbooks under Edison's name.
Edison did talk about persistence, in interviews and in his own notes, and his best-known line on it, that genius is mostly perspiration, was printed while he was alive. That may be why this one was so easy to believe: it sounds like him. The same thing happened to another line about giving up that carries his name, to Marie Curie's “be less curious about people” and to the cure for boredom.
The idea holds up in mathematics as well as anywhere. Most proofs are found after many attempts that do not work, and the people who find them are the ones who go back to the problem the next morning. Feynman put the attitude well in his letter on being born not knowing.
Attributed; first printed in 1958
Who was Thomas Edison?
- Born
- 11 February 1847, Milan, Ohio
- Died
- 18 October 1931, West Orange, New Jersey
- Known for
- Phonograph, electric light, power stations
- First printed
- Mechanix Illustrated, June 1958
Thomas Alva Edison was born in Milan, Ohio, in 1847, had only a few months of formal schooling and became partly deaf as a boy. He started as a telegraph operator, made his first money from an improved stock ticker, and in 1876 set up a laboratory at Menlo Park that worked like a factory for inventions.
There he invented the phonograph (1877), built a practical incandescent lamp and the power system to run it, opening the Pearl Street station in Manhattan in 1882, and later developed motion picture cameras and storage batteries at a larger laboratory in West Orange. He held 1,093 US patents. He died in West Orange, New Jersey, in October 1931.
Read next
The Wizard of Menlo Park
Randall E. Stross · 2007
A sharp, readable biography that separates Edison the inventor from Edison the legend, including how much of his fame he and the newspapers made together. It explains why so many lines like this one ended up with his name on them.
Questions
About this quote
Did Thomas Edison say “Our greatest weakness lies in giving up”?
There is no evidence he did. The earliest known printing is Robert Mines's article “Don't Give Up!” in Mechanix Illustrated, June 1958, which credits Edison without a source. Edison died in 1931.
Where did the quote first appear?
In Mechanix Illustrated, June 1958, in a paragraph that also claims Edison said 75 per cent of failures would have succeeded if they had kept at it. Quote magazine reprinted it on 13 July 1958.
How many times did Edison fail before inventing the light bulb?
His team tested many hundreds of filament materials in 1879 and later thousands of plant fibres. The popular round numbers, such as 1,000 or 10,000 failures, come from later retellings rather than from his notebooks.
Is the advice still good?
Yes, whoever wrote it. Most real discoveries, in the lab or in mathematics, come after many attempts that fail.




