The source
The exact words
“Many of life's failures are men who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up.”
Unknown; earliest printings are anonymous. Westwood (Massachusetts) High School yearbook, 1982, unattributed. Credited to Edison by 1991 in motivational collections such as Larry Winget's The Ya Gotta's for Success.
This is the oldest wording found, with “men” rather than “people”. It appears without any name in American high-school yearbooks of 1982 and 1986, and is credited to Edison in self-help collections from the early 1990s. A 2007 children's book dates it to 1877 but gives no source, and nothing from Edison's lifetime has been found.
The story
Where the line really comes from
Search old books and magazines for this sentence and you do not find Edison. You find seniors. In the 1982 yearbook of Westwood High School in Massachusetts, one student chose it as a farewell line, with no author at all. In 1986 another student, at another school, picked it too, still without a name. Its wording then was “Many of life's failures are men who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up.”
By the late 1980s it was turning up in gift books of business and success quotations, sometimes anonymous, and by the early 1990s motivational writers were signing it “Thomas Edison”. Later collections softened “men” to “people”, and that is the version printed on posters today. A 2007 children's biography of Edison goes further and dates the line to 1877, the year of the phonograph, but gives no source, and Wikiquote's editors removed it from his page for that reason.
Why Edison? Because he is the patron saint of trying again. A generation earlier the same thing had happened to “Our greatest weakness lies in giving up”, which first appeared in a 1958 magazine article, also with no source. A line about persistence sounds more convincing with the man who tested a thousand filaments behind it, and so it drifts toward him.
The image on the collage, of a tunnel abandoned a few inches from the gold, is an old one. Napoleon Hill told a version of it in 1937, about a miner who sold his claim three feet from a seam of gold. In mathematics it happens too: proofs are abandoned one idea short, and finished years later by someone who kept going. For the opposite of giving up, read Erdős, who never stopped.
Attributed; first printed in 1982
Who was Thomas Edison?
- Born
- 11 February 1847, Milan, Ohio
- Died
- 18 October 1931, West Orange, New Jersey
- Known for
- Phonograph, electric light, power stations
- First printed
- Anonymous, 1982; as Edison's by 1991
Thomas Alva Edison was born in Milan, Ohio, in 1847, had only a few months of formal schooling and became partly deaf as a boy. He started as a telegraph operator, made his first money from an improved stock ticker, and in 1876 set up a laboratory at Menlo Park that worked like a factory for inventions.
There he invented the phonograph (1877), built a practical incandescent lamp and the power system to run it, and later developed motion picture cameras and storage batteries at a larger laboratory in West Orange. He held 1,093 US patents. He died in West Orange, New Jersey, in October 1931.
Read next
The Wizard of Menlo Park
Randall E. Stross · 2007
The best short biography for separating the real Edison from the legend that attracts lines like this one. Stross shows how much of the myth Edison and the press built together, and how much hard, repetitive work sat underneath it.
Questions
About this quote
Did Thomas Edison say “Many of life's failures are people who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up”?
There is no evidence he did. The earliest known printings are anonymous, in high-school yearbooks from 1982 and 1986. It was credited to Edison in motivational books from the early 1990s, sixty years after his death.
What was the original wording?
“Many of life's failures are men who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up.” Later versions changed “men” to “people”.
Is it from 1877?
That date comes from a 2007 children's book that gives no source. Nothing from 1877, or from anywhere in Edison's lifetime, has been found with these words.




