The source
The exact words
“There is geometry in the humming of the strings. There is music in the spacings of the spheres.”
Music of the Spheres, by Guy Murchie. Epigraph, credited to “Pythagoras, 5th century B.C.” Houghton Mifflin, Boston, 1961. No earlier printing and no Greek original are known.
No ancient source contains these words. The earliest known printing is the epigraph of Guy Murchie's Music of the Spheres (1961), credited to “Pythagoras, 5th century B.C.” with no reference. The ideas are genuinely Pythagorean; the sentences are modern.
The story
Where the line really comes from
Pythagoras left no writings, and perhaps never wrote anything at all. He taught by word of mouth on Samos and then at Croton in southern Italy, and his followers were famous for keeping his teachings among themselves. Almost everything we know about him comes from authors writing a century or many centuries later, from Aristotle to the Neoplatonists Porphyry and Iamblichus. None of them quotes anything like the line on the collage.
The earliest printing found so far is in Guy Murchie's Music of the Spheres, a popular book on astronomy and physics published in Boston in 1961. It stands at the front of the book as an epigraph, signed “Pythagoras, 5th century B.C.”, and one of the chapters is called “The Spacings of the Spheres”. Murchie gives no source, and the phrasing may well be his own summary of Pythagorean ideas. Three years later Evans G. Valens opened The Number of Things, subtitled Pythagoras, Geometry and Humming Strings, with the same lines, and from there they moved into dictionaries of quotations.
The ideas behind it, though, are genuinely Pythagorean. The strings: the Pythagoreans knew that the intervals that sound consonant come from simple whole-number ratios of string length. Stop a string at half its length and it sounds an octave higher (1 : 2); at two thirds it gives a fifth (2 : 3), at three quarters a fourth (3 : 4). Aristotle reports that they went on to suppose that the elements of numbers are the elements of all things, and that the whole heaven is a musical scale and a number. Two thousand years later Galileo's father Vincenzo tested the ratios with weighted strings and found the rule is subtler for tension, one of the first experiments in modern acoustics.
The spheres: Aristotle describes the Pythagorean belief that the stars and planets make a sound as they move, a harmony we never notice because we have heard it since birth. Pliny the Elder even gives Pythagoras' spacing in musical intervals: a tone from the Earth to the Moon, a semitone to Mercury, another to Venus, a tone and a half to the Sun, and so on to the fixed stars, seven tones in all. That is the scale the orbits on the collage are drawn to. Kepler took the idea seriously enough to write The Harmony of the World (1619), in which he found his third law.
Attributed; first printed in 1961
Who was Pythagoras?
- Born
- About 570 BC, Samos
- Died
- About 495 BC, Metapontum
- Known for
- Musical ratios, the Pythagorean school
- First printed
- Guy Murchie, 1961
Pythagoras was born on the island of Samos around 570 BC. Around 530 BC he moved to Croton in southern Italy and founded a community that was part school and part religious brotherhood, with rules about diet and silence and a belief in the transmigration of souls. After a political backlash he seems to have moved to Metapontum, where he is said to have died around 495 BC.
The theorem that carries his name was known to Babylonian scribes more than a thousand years earlier, and there is no ancient evidence that he proved it. What his school did leave is the conviction that number underlies the world, from musical harmony to the cosmos, an idea that runs through Galileo and everything after. Later Greeks credited him with the words “philosophy” and “cosmos”, though that too may be legend.
Read next
The Music of Pythagoras
Kitty Ferguson · 2008
A readable history of what is known about Pythagoras and what was made up later, from the string ratios and the music of the spheres to Kepler and modern physics. It is honest about how thin the ancient evidence is, which is exactly what this quote needs.
Questions
About this quote
Did Pythagoras say “There is geometry in the humming of the strings”?
There is no evidence he did. Pythagoras left no writings, and no ancient author quotes these words. The earliest known printing is the epigraph of Guy Murchie's Music of the Spheres (1961), which credits Pythagoras without giving a source.
What did Pythagoras discover about strings?
The Pythagoreans found that consonant musical intervals come from simple ratios of string length: half the string gives the octave (1 : 2), two thirds the fifth (2 : 3) and three quarters the fourth (3 : 4).
What is the music of the spheres?
The Pythagorean idea that the planets, moving in their orbits, produce a harmony. Aristotle says they explained our not hearing it by the fact that we have heard it since birth. Pliny reports that Pythagoras spaced the planets by musical intervals, seven tones from the Earth to the stars.
Did Pythagoras write any books?
None survive, and ancient writers already doubted he wrote any. The earliest Pythagorean writings we have fragments of are by Philolaus, a generation or two after him.




