Most things put up with a great deal before they change. You can pull on a spring and it only gets longer. You can lean a stack of blocks and it only leans. You can slide a magnet toward a piece of steel and the steel sits where it is. Then, at one particular moment, the spring gives, the stack falls and the steel jumps. Nothing about the pulling, leaning or sliding was different in that last instant. A limit was reached.
Unendurable Line is a two-minute film about that instant. The Japanese designer Daihei Shibata made it in 2017 for Design Ah, the children’s design programme on NHK’s educational channel. It films a series of ordinary objects being pushed slowly toward the point where they give way, and next to each one it draws a graph in real time. A line climbs as the object is stretched, spun or loaded. A second line marks the limit. You watch the first approach the second, and you know exactly what is about to happen and roughly when. It is surprisingly tense.
The film’s own description calls its subject the thresholds hidden in everyday life. The music is by the composer Yasuharu Fukushima and sung by the EX NOVO Chamber Choir, whose voices give each object its own short score. A child can follow it, which was the brief, and a physicist can enjoy it for the same reason.

The frame above shows how it works. On the right is a shishi-odoshi, the bamboo fountain found in Japanese gardens. Water trickles into a hollow tube balanced on a pivot. As the tube fills, its centre of mass creeps forward, and for a long while nothing else happens. On the left, the black line climbs toward the red one. When it touches, the weight of the water has passed the pivot: the tube tips, empties, and swings back to start again. The graph falls straight down and begins another climb. The result is a sawtooth, a slow rise and a sudden drop repeated for as long as the water runs.
The idea
What a threshold is
A threshold is a value that separates two different kinds of behaviour. Below it the system does one thing, above it another, and the change between them is sudden even when the cause is gradual. The graph of the cause is a smooth curve. The graph of the effect is a step.
That mismatch is why thresholds are easy to miss. Up to the last moment, everything you can see says that nothing is happening. The film’s trick is to draw the quantity you cannot see, so that the surprise turns into suspense.
The cause is a smooth curve. The effect is a step.
The objects
Four lines that cannot be crossed
The film does not explain its objects, so here is the physics behind four of the kinds it uses. In each case there is one quantity that grows and one limit it runs into.
A spring
force vs. elastic limitPull a spring and it pulls back in proportion to how far you have stretched it. This is Hooke’s law, F = kx, and while it holds the spring returns to its old length when you let go. Every spring also has an elastic limit. Stretch it past that and the metal itself deforms, and it will never be the same length again.
A magnet
pull vs. frictionA piece of steel on a table is held in place by friction, which can resist any sideways force up to a fixed maximum. The pull of a magnet grows very quickly as the gap closes. For most of the approach friction wins and nothing moves. At the distance where the pull first exceeds what friction can supply, the steel leaps across the gap all at once.
A spinning top
spin rate vs. critical speedA top stays upright because it is spinning, and only while it spins fast enough. Friction at the tip slows it a little with every turn. Above a critical rate it stands almost still. Below that rate it starts to wobble, the wobble grows, and it falls over.
A stack of blocks
centre of mass vs. edgeA stack stands as long as its centre of mass is above its base. Slide the top blocks outward and the centre of mass moves with them. The moment it passes the edge of the block underneath, the stack tips. With care you can go a long way first: four identical blocks can be staggered so that the top one lies entirely beyond the edge of the table, since ½ × (1 + ½ + ⅓ + ¼) is a little more than one block length.
Beyond the film
The same line, everywhere
Once you have seen the film you start to notice how much of the world works this way. Water warms steadily and then, at 100 °C, boils. A drinking straw carries more and more weight along its length and then buckles, which is the subject of how strong a drinking straw is. A bridge made of pasta holds one more coin, and one more, until the spaghetti bridge breaks. A nerve cell collects small signals and fires only when their sum passes a set level. Thirty-two metronomes tick out of step until the coupling between them is strong enough, and then they fall into time together.
Engineers spend much of their working lives finding these lines and staying a safe distance below them. That distance is the safety factor, and it is why a lift rated for eight people does not fall when a ninth steps in. The limit is still there, only further off than the sign says.
The film belongs with a small group of Japanese shorts that make one idea visible with very plain means, like Tomohiro Okazaki’s matchsticks and Takahiro Kurashima’s Poemotion. For a machine that never reaches its limit at all, there is the LEGO Sisyphus, who pushes his boulder forever.
Try it at home
Fill a glass to the brim and add coins one at a time, counting as you go. The water rises above the rim and holds, bulging, far longer than seems possible. Plot coins against time on a sheet of paper and draw a dashed line where it finally spills. You have made your own unendurable line, and the thing holding it up was surface tension.
Credits
- Unendurable Line, directed by Daihei Shibata, 2017. Made for Design Ah (NHK Educational TV).
- Music by Yasuharu Fukushima, performed by the EX NOVO Chamber Choir.
- Film still © Daihei Shibata. Threshold diagram and physics notes by Abakcus.






