Abakcus
← All videos

Video · Mathematics · Symmetry

Symmetry

Two half-faces, two strangers, one line down the middle. They almost match, and the almost is the point.

Symmetry · Everynone for Radiolab · 2011

The screen is split down the middle. On each side a different film is playing, and the two have been lined up so that they meet at the seam. A girl’s face on the left, a boy’s on the right, cut at the bridge of the nose so that together they make one face. Other pairs follow, built around opposites such as birth and death, heart and head, male and female. For three minutes, without a word of narration, the film keeps finding pairs that nearly fit.

Symmetry was made in 2011 by Everynone, the New York filmmaking trio of Will Hoffman, Daniel Mercadante and Julius Metoyer III, for the radio programme Radiolab. It accompanied an hour-long episode called “Desperately Seeking Symmetry”, which followed the idea from the origin of the universe to the face in the bathroom mirror. Radiolab’s own note on the film says it shows how beautiful imperfect matches can be. That is a good summary, and it is also a mathematical claim.

A frame from Symmetry: the left half of a girl's face with grey eyes and freckles beside the right half of a boy's face with blue eyes, split by a thin black line, together forming one face
A frame from the film. Two children, two halves, one face that is not quite either of them.

The definition

What mathematicians mean by symmetry

In everyday speech, symmetric means balanced, or the same on both sides. Mathematics makes the idea precise. A symmetry of a shape is a move that leaves it looking exactly as it did before: a turn, a flip, a slide. The shape is more symmetric the more such moves it has.

The flip that matters for faces is reflection in a vertical line. Put the mirror line on the y-axis and reflection sends every point (x, y) to (−x, y). A shape has mirror symmetry if that move maps it onto itself. A square has four such lines, and can also be turned by a quarter, a half or three-quarters of a full turn, so it has eight symmetries in all, counting the move that does nothing. An idealised face has only two: doing nothing, and the one mirror down its middle.

84 rotations + 4 reflections2do nothing + 1 reflection
Mirror lines are dashed. A square can be turned or flipped eight ways and look unchanged. An idealised face has only one mirror. A real face has none that works exactly.

Those eight moves for the square can be combined, and any two of them in a row give another one on the list. A collection like that is called a group, and the study of symmetry is, to a large extent, the study of groups. It is the reason a kaleidoscope works: two mirrors set at 60° to each other produce six copies of whatever lies between them, because 360 ÷ 60 = 6, and the pattern you see has exactly the symmetries of that arrangement.

The face

No one is their own mirror image

Human bodies are built on a plan of bilateral symmetry, one left and one right, like those of most animals. The plan is never carried out perfectly. One eye sits a little higher, one side of the jaw is a little fuller, one eyebrow arches differently. Most of these differences are a few millimetres, and we rarely notice them in other people.

You can make them visible with a simple trick. Take a straight-on photograph of a face, cut it down the middle, and build two new faces: one from the left half and its mirror image, the other from the right half and its mirror image. Both new faces are perfectly symmetric, and they usually look like two different people, neither of whom is quite the person in the original photograph.

Studies since the 1990s have found that people tend to rate more symmetric faces as somewhat more attractive, though the effect is modest and perfectly mirrored composites often look oddly lifeless. The film goes the other way. It joins halves of two different people, faces that are plainly not mirror images, and the seam still feels right. The eye is looking for balance, not for an exact copy.

A perfect mirror image looks strange. A near-miss looks like a person.

The universe

Symmetry, and where it breaks

The idea goes much further than faces. In 1918 the mathematician Emmy Noether proved that every continuous symmetry of a physical law comes with a quantity that is conserved. If the laws are the same today as tomorrow, energy is conserved. If they are the same here as a metre to the left, momentum is conserved. If they do not change when you turn around, angular momentum is conserved. Some of the most basic rules in physics turn out to be symmetries in disguise.

And some of the most interesting facts are places where symmetry fails. The equations of particle physics treat matter and antimatter almost exactly alike, so the early universe should have made equal amounts of each, and they should have annihilated one another. Yet the universe around us is made almost entirely of matter. Why the balance tipped is still an open question, and it is the reason there is anything to see at all, faces included.

The film

Why the near-misses work

The film never explains any of this, and it does not need to. Its method is the argument. Two shots that match exactly would be dull, a single image doubled. Two shots that do not match at all would be noise. The pleasure is in between, in pairs that agree on the shape and disagree on everything else, so your eye keeps checking one side against the other.

It is the same pleasure Richard Feynman describes in his short talk on beauty, where knowing how a flower works adds to its beauty instead of taking it away, and the one collected in The Beauty of Numbers in Nature, where shells and leaves follow patterns without ever repeating them exactly. For a different kind of short film about the hidden rule behind an everyday event, try Unendurable Line; for one about scale rather than shape, Powers of Ten.

Try it at home

Print a straight-on photo of your own face. Stand a small mirror upright along the vertical line through the middle of your nose, so you see the left half and its reflection together. Then turn the mirror around for the right half. Compare the two faces, and decide which one looks more like you. Most people are surprised by the answer.

Credits

  • Symmetry, by Everynone (Will Hoffman, Daniel Mercadante and Julius Metoyer III) for Radiolab, WNYC, April 2011. Film still © Everynone.
  • Inspired by the Radiolab episode “Desperately Seeking Symmetry,” 18 April 2011.
  • Symmetry diagram by Abakcus.