Abakcus
← All videos

Video · Simulation · Nuclear War

Plan A: A Simulation of Nuclear War

Four minutes of lines on a map. One warning shot at the start, 91.5 million people dead or injured by the end.

Plan A · Alex Glaser and Princeton’s Program on Science and Global Security · 2019

The video has no narrator and no faces. It opens on a dark map of the world with country borders drawn in thin green lines, and for a moment nothing moves. Then a single line leaves a base near Kaliningrad, on the Baltic coast, and a white dot appears where it lands. That is the warning shot. Everything after it takes about four minutes to watch and, in the scenario, a few hours to happen.

Plan A was made in 2019 by Alex Glaser and his colleagues at Princeton University’s Program on Science and Global Security. It is a simulation, and that is the reason it belongs on a site about mathematics. Nobody drew these arcs by hand to look frightening. Each one stands for a real type of weapon, fired from a place where such weapons are based, at a target of the kind war planners are believed to choose. The casualty counts that tick up in the corner of the screen are computed from those inputs.

A frame from the Plan A simulation: hundreds of blue and orange missile arcs cross a black world map, with white dots marking detonations over North America, Europe and Russia
A frame from late in the simulation. Each arc is a missile or aircraft path and each white dot is a detonation.

The model

What goes into the simulation

The team describes three kinds of input. The first is the weapons themselves: how many warheads the United States and Russia have deployed, on which missiles, submarines and aircraft, and with what explosive yields. The second is the list of likely targets. The third is what the military calls the order of battle, meaning which weapons go to which targets, in what sequence, at each stage of a war. All of it comes from independent, public assessments of the two countries’ forces and war plans.

The human cost is then estimated with NUKEMAP, the tool built by the historian Alex Wellerstein, who worked on the project. Given a yield and a location, NUKEMAP lays rings of blast, heat and radiation over a map of where people live and counts the people inside each ring. Run that once and you have an estimate for one bomb on one city. Plan A runs it for every detonation in the scenario and adds the results.

The shape of the arcs is honest too. A long-range missile does not fly along a line of latitude. It follows the shortest path over the globe, which between North America and Russia runs over the Arctic. On a flat map those paths bend into the tall curves that fill the top of the screen, and a flight from one continent to the other takes about half an hour.

The scenario

Four steps from one shot to ninety million

The war in the video starts as a conventional one in Europe. Russia, hoping to stop a NATO advance, fires one nuclear warning shot from near Kaliningrad, and NATO answers with a single nuclear air strike. From there the scenario climbs in three phases.

In the tactical phase, Russia sends about 300 warheads by aircraft and short-range missile against NATO bases and troops in Europe, and NATO replies with about 180 delivered by aircraft. Europe is destroyed in three hours, at a cost of 2.6 million casualties.

In the second phase, with Europe gone, NATO launches about 600 warheads from American land-based missiles and submarines at Russia’s nuclear forces. Russia, with perhaps half an hour of warning, launches its own missiles from silos, trucks and submarines before they can be destroyed. Planners call this a counterforce exchange, because the weapons are aimed at other weapons. It lasts 45 minutes and adds 3.4 million casualties.

In the last phase each side tries to stop the other from recovering. Each aims five to ten warheads at every one of the other’s thirty largest cities and economic centres. This is the countervalue plan, and it also lasts 45 minutes.

Casualties by phase, in millions

  • Tactical plan3 hours
    2.6
  • Counterforce plan45 minutes
    3.4
  • Countervalue plan45 minutes
    85.3
Bars are drawn to scale. Deaths and injuries together, as estimated in the simulation.

Look at the three bars together. The first two phases, which use more than a thousand warheads between them, account for about 6 million casualties. The third accounts for 85.3 million, roughly 93 percent of the total, because it is the only one aimed at places where people live. During those 45 minutes the count rises by about 1.9 million people a minute, or more than thirty thousand every second.

91.5 million

The simulation’s final count: 34.1 million people killed and 57.4 million injured in the first few hours.

The limits

What the number leaves out

The authors are careful to say that these are immediate casualties only. The figure does not include deaths from radioactive fallout in the days and weeks afterwards, from the collapse of hospitals, water and food supply, or from the cooling of the climate that smoke from burning cities would cause. Later studies of that last effect put the possible toll from famine in the billions. So the count in the video is a lower bound.

It is also one scenario out of many. A model like this shows what follows if a war unfolds in a particular way. It makes no forecast about whether one will. Change the assumptions and the totals change. What stays the same across reasonable assumptions is the speed. The Second World War killed something like 70 to 85 million people over six years. The simulation reaches a comparable number of dead and injured in one afternoon.

The first two phases use more than a thousand warheads. Nine-tenths of the casualties come in the last 45 minutes.

Why it was made

A map as an argument

The project came out in September 2019, weeks after the treaty that had banned intermediate-range nuclear missiles in Europe since 1987 came to an end. The team said they wanted to show the consequences of the war plans both countries still hold, at a time when the agreements limiting those plans were being dropped one by one. The sound, a low electronic drone by the composer Jeff Snyder, is there for the same purpose: the video is meant to be uncomfortable.

It makes a natural pair with Trinity, the map of every nuclear detonation from 1945 to 2009, which records what has already happened using the same language of dots on a map. The road to the first of those dots is told in Einstein’s letter to Roosevelt and in the facts behind Oppenheimer, and the physics that makes a few kilograms of metal this destructive is in E = mc². For a kinder use of the same idea, a short film that changes how large the world feels, there is Powers of Ten.

In the classroom

The video works well as a lesson in reading a model. Ask three questions of it. What are the inputs, and where do they come from? What does the output count, and what does it leave out? Which assumption, if you changed it, would change the answer most? They are the questions to ask of any simulation, from a weather forecast to an epidemic curve.

Sources

  • “Plan A,” Alex Glaser, YouTube, 6 September 2019. Simulation by Alex Wellerstein, Tamara Patton, Moritz Kütt and Alex Glaser, with Bruce Blair, Sharon Weiner and Zia Mian. Sound by Jeff Snyder.
  • Plan A, Program on Science and Global Security, Princeton University: phases, warhead counts and casualty estimates.
  • Shares and rates per minute calculated by Abakcus from those figures.