Atiyah: “We Live on Beautiful Things”

Collage of Michael Atiyah smiling at the 2018 International Congress of Mathematicians in front of pale sunburst rays, on golden yellow
Photo: International Congress of Mathematicians 2018, Rio de Janeiro. Public domain.
“We as mathematicians don’t have to be apologetic about saying we like beautiful things. We live on beautiful things.”

Michael Atiyah, 2016

Lecture at the 4th Heidelberg Laureate Forum

The source

The exact words

“We as mathematicians don’t have to be apologetic about saying we like beautiful things. We live on beautiful things.”

Lecture at the 4th Heidelberg Laureate Forum. Heidelberg, Germany, 19 September 2016. Reported by Ben Orlin, “21 Essential Quotes from Sir Michael Atiyah”, HLF blog (SciLogs) and Math with Bad Drawings, 20 September 2016.

The wording comes from Ben Orlin's report of Atiyah's lecture at the 4th Heidelberg Laureate Forum, published the next day as part of a list of 21 lines from the talk. The talk was spoken, so the words are as noted down in the room.

The story

Why Atiyah said it

In September 2016 the Heidelberg Laureate Forum gathered Abel, Fields and Turing prize winners to talk with two hundred young researchers. On the Monday morning Michael Atiyah, then 87, gave a long, wandering lecture about how mathematics is made: about imagination, about Plato's perfect spheres that exist nowhere in the real world, and about beauty. The writer Ben Orlin sat in the audience and took down the best lines. This one came near the end.

Atiyah was arguing against a kind of embarrassment. Scientists are trained to talk about truth and usefulness, and to treat beauty as a private pleasure, a little unprofessional. Atiyah said mathematicians should stop apologizing. For them beauty is not decoration but a guide: it is how they decide which ideas are worth pursuing and which proofs are right, long before anyone checks every step.

He had tested the claim. In 2014 he joined the neurobiologist Semir Zeki and two colleagues in a study published in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. Fifteen mathematicians rated sixty formulas for beauty and then looked at them inside a brain scanner. The formulas they found beautiful lit up the same region of the brain, the medial orbitofrontal cortex, that responds to beautiful music and painting. The formula rated most beautiful most often was Euler's identity, eiπ + 1 = 0.

Atiyah belongs to a long line here. Hardy wrote that beauty is the first test and there is no permanent place for ugly mathematics, Erdős said that if numbers aren't beautiful, nothing is, and Dirac put beauty in equations above agreement with experiment. For Atiyah's other famous line, on algebra and geometry, read “deaf or blind?”.

Mathematician

Who was Michael Atiyah?

Born
22 April 1929, London
Died
11 January 2019, Edinburgh
Known for
Atiyah–Singer index theorem, K-theory
Said it
Heidelberg Laureate Forum, 2016

Michael Francis Atiyah was born in London in 1929 to a Lebanese father and a Scottish mother, and grew up in Khartoum and Cairo before studying at Trinity College, Cambridge. He spent most of his career at Oxford and Cambridge and at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton.

With Isadore Singer he proved the Atiyah–Singer index theorem (1963), which connects analysis, topology and geometry and later became a tool of theoretical physics; with Friedrich Hirzebruch he developed topological K-theory. He received the Fields Medal in 1966 and the Abel Prize in 2004, was President of the Royal Society and Master of Trinity, and was the first director of the Isaac Newton Institute in Cambridge. He died in Edinburgh in January 2019, at 89.

Read next

Cover: Proofs from THE BOOK by Martin Aigner and Günter M. Ziegler

Proofs from THE BOOK

Martin Aigner and Günter M. Ziegler · 1998

The most direct answer to Atiyah's claim: a collection of the most beautiful proofs the authors could find, from Euclid's primes to Euler's formula, each short enough to read in one sitting. It is what mathematicians mean when they say they live on beautiful things.

Questions

About this quote

Where did Atiyah say “We live on beautiful things”?

In his lecture at the 4th Heidelberg Laureate Forum on 19 September 2016. The line was reported the next day by Ben Orlin in “21 Essential Quotes from Sir Michael Atiyah”.

What was the 2014 study of mathematical beauty?

“The experience of mathematical beauty and its neural correlates” by Semir Zeki, John Romaya, Dionigi Benincasa and Michael Atiyah, in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. Mathematicians' brains responded to formulas they found beautiful in the same region that responds to beautiful art and music.

Which formula was rated most beautiful?

Euler's identity, e^iπ + 1 = 0, which links five of the most important numbers in mathematics in one short equation.

More quotes

All quotes