“Let No One Ignorant of Geometry Enter”: Was It Over Plato's Door?

Collage of the head of Plato, a Roman copy of Silanion's portrait, with compass-and-straightedge construction lines drawn over the face, on Aegean blue
Bust: Roman copy of Silanion's portrait of Plato, Glyptothek, Munich. Photo: Bibi Saint-Pol, public domain.
“Let no one ignorant of geometry enter.”

Attributed to Plato · first recorded in AD 362

Late commentators on Plato and Aristotle

The source

The exact words

“ἀγεωμέτρητος μηδεὶς εἰσίτω”

“Let no one ignorant of geometry enter.”

Late commentators on Plato and Aristotle. First mentioned by the emperor Julian (AD 362), without the words. The wording is in a scholion on Aelius Aristides perhaps by Sopatros (4th century), John Philoponus on Aristotle's On the Soul and Elias on the Categories (6th century), and Tzetzes, Chiliades VIII (12th century). See H. D. Saffrey, Revue des études grecques 81 (1968).

No source from Plato's time, or from Aristotle, who spent twenty years at the Academy, mentions the inscription. The oldest reference is in an oration of the emperor Julian in AD 362, without the wording; the Greek words appear in later commentaries, from about the fourth to the sixth century. The classic study, by H. D. Saffrey (1968), calls it a legendary inscription.

The story

Where the line really comes from

Plato founded his school around 387 BC in a grove outside Athens sacred to the hero Academus, which gave it its name, the Academy. Mathematics really was at its heart. In the Republic Plato makes arithmetic and geometry the first studies of future rulers, the Academy was home to Theaetetus and Eudoxus, two of the greatest Greek mathematicians, and Plato set his colleagues problems in solid geometry and astronomy.

The famous sign, though, has no witness from that world. Aristotle, who studied and taught at the Academy for twenty years, never mentions it, and neither does anyone else for seven centuries. The oldest reference is in a speech by the emperor Julian in AD 362, who speaks of an inscription at the entrance without saying what it read. The Greek words themselves first appear in a note on the orator Aelius Aristides, possibly by the fourth-century rhetorician Sopatros, and then in sixth-century commentaries on Aristotle by John Philoponus and Elias, who places it before a shrine of the Muses. The Byzantine scholar Tzetzes, in the twelfth century, puts it over the door of Plato's house.

The scholar H. D. Saffrey, who traced all these sources in 1968, called it a legendary inscription. The note on Aristides suggests where it came from: sacred places sometimes carried warnings such as “let no one unequal or unjust enter”, and the joke was to swap in “ungeometrical”, because, the commentator explains, geometry seeks equality and justice. That echoes Plato himself, whose Socrates tells the bully Callicles in the Gorgias that he has neglected geometry, since geometric equality has great power among gods and men.

Legend or not, the sign stuck. The Greek words are on the seal of the American Mathematical Society. And Plato's real view of learning mathematics was gentler than a warning on a door: children, he said, should be led to it not by force but by play. Galileo took his advice and started with mathematics, and for another line with a great name attached long afterwards, see Pythagoras on the humming of the strings.

Attributed; legend of the Academy's door

Who was Plato?

Born
About 428 BC, Athens
Died
About 348 BC, Athens
Founded
The Academy, about 387 BC
First mentioned
Emperor Julian, AD 362

Plato was born into an aristocratic Athenian family around 428 BC and became the most devoted follower of Socrates. After Socrates was executed in 399 BC he travelled, met Pythagorean mathematicians in southern Italy, and around 387 BC founded the Academy, the school where Aristotle studied for twenty years.

He wrote about thirty dialogues, almost all starring Socrates, including the Republic, the Symposium and the Timaeus, where the four elements are built from the regular solids still called Platonic. The Academy outlived him by centuries, and the portrait on the collage is a Roman copy of the statue of Plato that the sculptor Silanion made for it. He died in Athens around 348 BC.

Read next

The Mathematics of Plato's Academy

David Fowler · 1987

The best book on what was really studied at the Academy, from ratios and the theory of proportion to the problems Plato set his students. Fowler discusses the inscription and Saffrey's findings, and rebuilds the mathematics behind the legend.

Questions

About this quote

Was “Let no one ignorant of geometry enter” really written over Plato's Academy?

Probably not. No source from Plato's lifetime or for seven centuries after mentions it. The first reference is by the emperor Julian in AD 362, and the wording appears only in later commentators. Scholars treat it as a legend.

What is the inscription in Greek?

ἀγεωμέτρητος μηδεὶς εἰσίτω (ageōmetrētos mēdeis eisitō), literally “let no one ungeometrical enter”.

What did it mean?

One ancient commentator explained it as a play on warnings at sacred places against the unequal and unjust, since geometry was thought to teach equality and justice. Plato's Gorgias makes the same connection.

Where can you see the inscription today?

On the seal of the American Mathematical Society, which carries the Greek words.

More quotes

All quotes