The source
The exact words
“There are then two mathematics. There is the real mathematics of the real mathematicians, and there is what I call the ‘trivial’ mathematics, for want of a better word. The trivial mathematics may be justified by arguments which would appeal to Hogben, or other writers of his school, but there is no such defence for the real mathematics, which must be justified as art if it can be justified at all.”
A Mathematician's Apology. Section 28. Cambridge University Press, 1940.
The words are Hardy's, but the popular version rebuilds his sentence. In the book the phrase is a clause about “the real mathematics”, which has no practical defence, set against the useful “trivial” mathematics of school and engineering.
The story
Why Hardy said it
Late in A Mathematician's Apology Hardy finally faces the question his title promises to answer: what good is mathematics? He has two opponents in mind. Lancelot Hogben, whose best seller Mathematics for the Million sold mathematics as a tool of social progress, and Alfred North Whitehead, who had praised its “tremendous effect” on daily life.
Hardy's reply is to split the subject in two. There is the mathematics of engineers, bookkeepers and school examinations, which is useful and which he calls, a little cruelly, trivial. And there is real mathematics, the mathematics of Fermat, Euler, Gauss and Riemann, which he admits is almost entirely useless. Useful arguments cannot defend it. So, he concludes in section 28, it must be justified as art if it can be justified at all, and he adds that there is nothing paradoxical about this: it is what most mathematicians believe.
The collage hangs Hardy himself on a gallery wall. The kind of picture he meant is Euclid's proof that there is no largest prime, which he gives in section 12 as an example of first-rate mathematics. Multiply all the primes up to p and add 1, and the new number cannot be divided by any of them, so there is always another prime. It has not aged in 2,300 years, which is exactly Hardy's argument for why Archimedes will outlast Aeschylus.
History has been unkind to one half of his case. He wrote in the same section that no one had found any warlike purpose for the theory of numbers or relativity. The number theory he was proudest of being useless now protects every online payment, and relativity sits behind both nuclear energy and satellite navigation. But the other half stands: mathematicians still choose their problems for beauty first, as he argued when he called a mathematician a maker of patterns, and as Atiyah said seventy years later. Read the essay on our A Mathematician's Apology page.
Mathematician
Who was G. H. Hardy?
- Born
- 7 February 1877, Cranleigh
- Died
- 1 December 1947, Cambridge
- Known for
- Analysis, number theory, the Apology
- Wrote it
- A Mathematician's Apology, 1940
Godfrey Harold Hardy was born in Cranleigh, Surrey, in 1877, the son of two teachers, and was educated at Winchester and Trinity College, Cambridge. He was the leading English pure mathematician of his generation.
His collaboration with J. E. Littlewood reshaped analysis and number theory, and he wrote the classic textbook A Course of Pure Mathematics. He was Savilian Professor at Oxford from 1919 and Sadleirian Professor at Cambridge from 1931. He wrote the Apology in 1940, after a heart attack had convinced him that his creative years were over, and died in Cambridge in December 1947.
Read next
Questions
About this quote
Where did Hardy say “Real mathematics must be justified as art”?
In section 28 of A Mathematician's Apology (1940). His sentence reads that there is no such defence for the real mathematics, “which must be justified as art if it can be justified at all.”
What did Hardy mean by real and trivial mathematics?
Real mathematics is the deep, permanent mathematics of the great mathematicians, which he thought almost entirely useless. Trivial mathematics is the useful kind taught in school and used by engineers and economists.
Was Hardy right that real mathematics is useless?
Not entirely. The number theory he admired now underlies public-key cryptography, and relativity, which he was sure had no warlike use, is part of the physics of nuclear energy. His point about beauty as the reason for doing mathematics is still widely shared.





