“Perfect Numbers Like Perfect Men Are Very Rare”: Descartes?

Collage of René Descartes in Frans Hals's 1649 portrait mirrored down the middle into a perfectly symmetrical face, on pale steel blue
Portrait: Frans Hals, 1649. Statens Museum for Kunst, Copenhagen.
“Perfect numbers like perfect men are very rare.”

Attributed to René Descartes · first recorded in 1624

Récréation mathématique, Problem 70

The source

The exact words

“Le nombre de 6 est premier entre ceux que les Arithmeticiens nomment parfaits, c'est à dire égaux à toutes leurs parties aliquotes : car 1, 2, 3, font 6. Or c'est merveille de voir combien peu il y en a de semblables, & combien rares sont les nombres aussi bien que les hommes parfaicts.”

“The number 6 is the first of those that arithmeticians call perfect, that is, equal to the sum of all their parts: for 1, 2 and 3 make 6. Now it is a marvel to see how few there are like it, and how rare such numbers are, just as perfect men are.”

Récréation mathématique, Problem 70. Pont-à-Mousson, 1624, published as by H. van Etten (usually attributed to Jean Leurechon). Reprinted with Claude Mydorge's notes in the Examen (Paris, 1630; 1639 edition) and in Œuvres de Descartes, ed. Adam and Tannery, vol. X. The English line is quoted as Descartes's in H. Eves, Mathematical Circles Squared (1972).

The comparison is real, but it is not Descartes's. It comes from Problem 70 of Récréation mathématique (1624), a popular French puzzle book published under the name H. van Etten and usually attributed to the Jesuit Jean Leurechon. Adam and Tannery reprinted the passage in a supplement to Descartes's works because the book circulated in his circle. The short English version credited to Descartes is first found in Howard Eves's Mathematical Circles Squared (1972), without a source.

The story

Where the line really comes from

A perfect number is one that equals the sum of its divisors, not counting itself. Six is the first: 1 + 2 + 3 = 6. Then comes 28 = 1 + 2 + 4 + 7 + 14, then 496 and 8128, all four known to the Greeks. Euclid showed how to build them: whenever 2ⁿ − 1 is prime, 2ⁿ⁻¹(2ⁿ − 1) is perfect. After that they thin out fast.

The line on the collage first appears, in French, in Récréation mathématique, a book of mathematical tricks and puzzles printed at Pont-à-Mousson in 1624 under the name H. van Etten, now usually credited to the Jesuit teacher Jean Leurechon. Problem 70, on rare properties of numbers, says it is a marvel how few perfect numbers there are, rare like perfect men, and that between 1 and 40,000,000 there are seven. Its list was 6, 28, 496, 8128, 130816, 1996128 and 33550336. Two of those are not perfect at all: 130816 = 2⁸ × 511, and 511 = 7 × 73 is not prime. There are only five perfect numbers in that range. The joke about rarity was truer than the book knew.

Why Descartes? The book was read and argued over in his circle in Paris, and his friend Claude Mydorge published a corrected Examen of it in 1630, so the editors of Descartes's collected works, Adam and Tannery, reprinted the passage in a supplement. Descartes did think hard about perfect numbers. In letters to Marin Mersenne in 1638 he said he could prove that every even perfect number has Euclid's form, and that an odd one, if it existed, would have to be a prime times a square; the same year he found the amicable pair 9,363,584 and 9,437,056. But the sentence is not in his letters. The English version, “Perfect numbers like perfect men are very rare,” with his name on it, first appears in Howard Eves's Mathematical Circles Squared (1972).

Leonhard Euler later proved that every even perfect number is one of Euclid's, and each new one still waits on a new Mersenne prime: only 52 had been found by the end of 2024. Whether an odd perfect number exists is one of the oldest unsolved problems in mathematics. For more on the primes behind them, read our tour of interesting prime numbers, and for books, our list of the best number theory books. Other famous lines with the wrong name on them include Pythagoras on the humming of the strings.

Attributed; from a 1624 book of puzzles

Who was René Descartes?

Born
31 March 1596, La Haye, Touraine
Died
11 February 1650, Stockholm
Known for
Coordinate geometry, “I think, therefore I am”
First printed
Récréation mathématique, 1624

René Descartes was born in La Haye, in Touraine, in 1596 and educated by the Jesuits at La Flèche. After studying law and serving as a volunteer soldier, he spent most of his working life in the Dutch Republic, where he wrote the Discourse on Method (1637) and the Meditations (1641).

The Geometry, an appendix to the Discourse, joined algebra to geometry by describing curves with equations, the idea behind the coordinate system that still carries his name. He also worked on optics, the rainbow and the laws of motion. In 1649 he went to Stockholm to teach Queen Christina, and he died there in February 1650.

Read next

Cover: Fermat's Enigma by Simon Singh

Fermat's Enigma

Simon Singh · 1997

Singh opens his story of Fermat's Last Theorem with the perfect and amicable numbers that obsessed Descartes, Fermat and Mersenne, and quotes this very line. It is the best way into number theory as a detective story.

Questions

About this quote

Did Descartes say “Perfect numbers like perfect men are very rare”?

Not as far as anyone can show. The comparison first appears in Récréation mathématique (1624), a French puzzle book usually attributed to Jean Leurechon, and the English line was credited to Descartes in 1972 by Howard Eves, without a source.

What is a perfect number?

A whole number equal to the sum of its divisors other than itself. The first four are 6, 28, 496 and 8128.

How many perfect numbers are there?

Every known one is even, and each comes from a Mersenne prime. Only 52 had been found by the end of 2024. No one knows whether there are infinitely many, or whether an odd perfect number exists.

What did Descartes actually write about perfect numbers?

In letters to Mersenne in 1638 he claimed that every even perfect number has Euclid's form, and that an odd perfect number would have to be a prime times a square. Euler later proved the first claim.

More quotes

All quotes