Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Abakcus earns a small commission at no extra cost to you.
These two are probably the most compared programs in homeschool math, and they couldn’t be more different. Saxon is the king of spiral review: small steps, everything practised every day. Singapore is the king of mastery: one idea at a time, understood deeply, with fewer problems.
Neither is “better.” They’re built for different kids, and the right choice depends far more on your kid than on the programs.
Side by side
| Saxon Math | Singapore Math | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Spiral: small new steps, constant mixed review | Mastery: one topic at a time, in depth |
| Lesson feel | Predictable, routine, lots of problems | Short, visual, fewer but richer problems |
| Who teaches | You at first, then mostly the kid from the book | You, with the teacher’s guide |
| Your time | Medium | High |
| Strongest at | Retention and fluency | Understanding and word problems |
| Grades | K to Calculus | Pre-K to 8th grade |
| Looks | Black and white, plain | Colorful and illustrated |
| Cost | $$ (very cheap used) | $$ |
Which one fits your kid?
Choose
Saxon Math if…
- Your kid forgets things quickly
- Your kid likes routine and knowing what’s next
- You want one program through high school
- You need your kid to work more on their own
Choose
Singapore Math if…
- Your kid wants to know why
- Your kid gets bored repeating things
- You’re happy to teach every lesson
- Word problems are a weak spot
Our honest take
If your biggest worry is your kid forgetting last month’s math, Saxon is hard to beat. If your biggest worry is your kid not understanding what they’re doing, Singapore is the stronger choice.
For a confident parent with a curious kid, Singapore usually leads to the stronger thinker. For a busy family with a kid who needs repetition, Saxon’s steady routine often wins.
Questions parents ask
Is Saxon or Singapore Math better?
Neither is better overall. Saxon suits kids who forget quickly and like routine; Singapore suits kids who want to understand deeply and parents who will teach each lesson.
Can I switch from Saxon to Singapore Math?
Yes. Use Singapore’s placement test, and expect your kid may place a level lower at first, since Singapore can run ahead in some topics. They usually catch up quickly.
Which is easier for parents, Saxon or Singapore?
Saxon is usually easier for parents, especially in the upper levels where kids can work from the book. Singapore asks you to teach each lesson with the teacher’s guide.
Still weighing options?
See all 13 programs side by side, with quick picks and a finder.
