Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Abakcus earns a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Both of these run from the early years all the way to calculus, and both have huge homeschool followings. But they solve different problems. Saxon’s answer to “my kid forgets” is daily review of everything. Math-U-See’s answer to “I can’t explain this” is a teacher on video and blocks you can hold.
Side by side
| Saxon Math | Math-U-See | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Spiral: everything reviewed daily | Mastery: one main topic per level |
| Who teaches | You (or the kid reads the book) | A teacher on video |
| Hands-on | In the primary levels | Blocks in every elementary lesson |
| Your time | Medium | Low |
| Levels | Grade-ish numbers (5/4, 6/5…) | Greek letters (Alpha, Beta…) |
| Strongest at | Retention | Concrete understanding |
| Cost | $$ (cheap used) | $$$ |
Which one fits your kid?
Choose
Saxon Math if…
- Your kid needs constant review
- You’re on a budget and happy buying used
- Your kid likes routine
- You’re fine teaching or checking from the book
Choose
Math-U-See if…
- You don’t want to explain math yourself
- Your kid learns with their hands
- Your kid gets overwhelmed by many topics at once
- Your kid is struggling and needs to slow down
Our honest take
If teaching is the problem, Math-U-See. If forgetting is the problem, Saxon. Math-U-See tends to be kinder to struggling and anxious kids; Saxon tends to suit steady kids who just need practice.
Questions parents ask
Is Math-U-See or Saxon better for a struggling learner?
Math-U-See is often the better fit for struggling kids, because it focuses on one topic at a time and uses blocks and video. Saxon can work if the problem is forgetting rather than understanding.
Which is cheaper, Saxon or Math-U-See?
Saxon is usually cheaper, especially bought used. Math-U-See costs more up front, but the blocks and instruction packs can be reused for siblings.
Can I switch from Saxon to Math-U-See?
Yes. Take Math-U-See’s placement test. Levels are named by topic, not grade, so your kid will start wherever their skills are.
Still weighing options?
See all 13 programs side by side, with quick picks and a finder.
