Abakcus
← All articles

Photography · Symmetry · Science

Wilson BentleyThe farmer who photographed 5,000 snowflakes

In 1885 a Vermont farm boy fixed a camera to a microscope and caught a snow crystal on glass. He spent the next 46 winters doing it again.

1885
first photograph of a snow crystal
5,000+
crystals photographed
6
fold symmetry, every time
Photomicrograph by Wilson Bentley of an ornate stellar snow crystal with fern-like branches, white against black.
One of Bentley’s lantern slides. The crystal was a few millimetres across.

Jericho, Vermont, gets about three metres of snow in a good winter, and in the 1870s a boy named Wilson Bentley was more interested in it than in the family farm. His mother had been a schoolteacher. She owned a small microscope, and when he was fifteen she let him have it. He put everything under the lens, as children do, but it was a snowflake that stopped him. He tried to draw what he saw. The crystals melted before he could finish.

So he asked for a camera. His father, a practical man, thought it a waste of money and bought it anyway. Bentley bolted the bellows to the microscope, failed for more than a year, and on 15 January 1885, a month short of his twentieth birthday, developed a glass plate with a snow crystal on it. Nobody had done that before.

The method

A black tray, a feather and held breath

The technique he worked out that winter barely changed for the rest of his life. He stood in an unheated shed with the door open and caught falling snow on a tray painted black. A turkey feather swept away the duds. When a promising crystal landed he lifted it with a splinter of wood, pressed it flat on a glass slide with the feather, and carried it to the camera, holding his breath so as not to melt it. Everything had to stay below freezing, including him.

The crystals were photographed with light shining through them, which gives a pale shape on a pale ground. Bentley wanted black. So he took a knife to a copy of each negative and scraped the emulsion away around the crystal, following every branch by hand. That is why the flakes in the slides below seem to hang in the night sky, and why, if you look at the corners of some of them, you can see where his blade stopped.

I

Plates

Slides 01–11

When the air is cold and fairly dry, a snow crystal grows slowly and stays flat: a hexagon of ice thinner than paper. The markings inside are ridges, hollows and trapped bubbles, each one a record of a moment in the cloud.

The geometry

Why six, and why all six arms agree

A water molecule is bent, and when water freezes the molecules lock together in a lattice of hexagonal rings. A snow crystal is that lattice repeated a few quintillion times, which is why it has six sides and never five or eight. Johannes Kepler guessed something of the kind in 1611, in a short essay on the six-cornered snowflake that he wrote as a New Year’s gift, three centuries before anyone could check.

Mathematically, an ideal snowflake has twelve symmetries: six rotations and six mirror reflections, the full symmetry group of the regular hexagon. In practice that means a crystal only has to design one twelfth of itself. The rest is copying.

The harder question is how one arm knows what the other five are doing. It doesn’t. A crystal is so small that all six corners pass through the same temperature and humidity at the same instant as it falls. Each corner responds to the conditions in the same way, so the arms come out alike without consulting one another. And because no two crystals take exactly the same route down through a cloud, no two histories match. That is the real content of “no two alike”, a phrase Bentley did more than anyone to plant in the language.

Try it

Grow one arm, get six

This sketch designs a single arm and copies it round the hexagon. Dry air keeps the crystal a flat plate. Damp air makes the corners race outward and sprout side branches.

Crystal No. 1,885 · Stellar crystal

II

Stars

Slides 12–28

Add moisture and the six corners of a plate start to outrun its flat sides. Each corner becomes an arm, each arm sprouts side branches at sixty degrees, and the result is the stellar dendrite, the shape on every winter greeting card.

III

Rule breakers

Slides 29–30

Not every crystal is a flat six-pointed thing. Some grow three sides faster than the other three and come out triangular. Others start as a column in one layer of cloud, drift into different air, and grow a plate on each end, like an axle with two wheels. The lattice underneath is hexagonal all the same.

A caveat

He chose the pretty ones

Bentley’s archive is not a fair sample of what falls from the sky. Most snow crystals are lopsided, broken or stuck together in clumps, and he swept those off the tray. He photographed the rare, nearly perfect ones, and the knife work on his negatives tidied them further. The German meteorologist Gustav Hellmann said so at the time and accused him of improving on nature.

The criticism is fair and it has not hurt him much. He belongs with the other patient, self-appointed cataloguers: the Dutchman who mixed every watercolour he could think of in 1692, the painters of the USDA’s seven thousand fruit watercolours, Ramón y Cajal drawing neurons one at a time, or, in our own day, Albert Chamillard filling ledgers with pen strokes. None of them was asked to do it.

IV

Everything else water does

Slides 31–36

Snow was the obsession, not the limit. Bentley photographed frost on window panes, dew on spider webs and the woods around the farm. He showed them as lantern slides at his lectures, and a few in this set are coloured by hand.

He also measured rain. For several summers he let raindrops fall into a pan of sifted flour, baked the pellets of dough they made, and worked out the size of the drops from the size of the pellets. It was one of the first serious studies of raindrop sizes, and it complements what we know about how those same drops make a rainbow. He never left the farm, never married, and sold his slides to schools and universities for a few cents each.

“Every crystal was a masterpiece of design and no one design was ever repeated.”

Wilson A. Bentley, 1925

In November 1931 McGraw-Hill published Snow Crystals, with more than 2,400 of his photographs and a text by the physicist William J. Humphreys. A few weeks later Bentley walked home through a blizzard, caught pneumonia, and died at the farm on 23 December. He was sixty-six. The neighbours had called him Snowflake for most of his life, and not always kindly. It is the name on the exhibit in Jericho’s Old Red Mill now.

Sources