Identität: Euler’s Identity Built on a Garden Fence
In 2016 the Austrian artist Aldo Tolino cut the most admired equation in mathematics out of wood and hung it on a chain-link fence between two gardens.
The fence is the kind you stop seeing after a week: rusty diamond mesh, a concrete footing going green with moss, blackberry canes pushing through from the neighbour’s side. Fastened to it, in letters taller than the brambles, is a line that usually lives on blackboards. A looping wooden e. A small i and a π riding above it as the exponent. Two planks for the equals sign, a third for the minus, and a plain numeral one.
Aldo Tolino called the piece Identität, German for identity, and it survives as three photographs. They are best looked at in the order you would meet the fence on foot.
1
From the path
The whole sentence at once. The fence leans, so the equation leans with it, and the minus sign has slipped a few degrees off level. The lawn behind is mown; the strip in front is not.
2
At the fence
Square on, the wood starts to match its surroundings. The minus one lines up with a compost box of the same timber, and for a moment the right-hand side of the equation looks like garden furniture.
3
Up close
Near enough to see the grain, the knots and the saw marks. The letters are cut in a flowing italic, the way a mathematician would write them by hand, and the blackberries have already begun to climb the e.
The equation
Five symbols and half a turn
Euler’s identity is usually printed as eiπ + 1 = 0, a form people like because it puts five famous constants in one line. Tolino built the older, blunter version: eiπ = −1. It says the same thing with one fewer piece of wood, and it is the form that tells you what is actually happening.
In 1748 Leonhard Euler published the formula eiθ = cos θ + i sin θ. Read geometrically, it says that raising e to an imaginary power does not make a number grow. It makes it turn. The value eiθ is the point you reach by starting at 1 and walking a distance θ around a circle of radius one. A full lap is 2π. Stop at π and you have gone exactly half way round, to the point directly opposite where you began. That point is −1.
Try it
Walk half way round
The point is eiθ. Start at 1 and travel a distance θ along the circle. When you have covered π, exactly half the circumference, you are standing on −1.
In mathematics an identity is an equation that holds without conditions. It is not solved; it is simply true, on both sides, always. On his website Tolino sets the photographs beside a different definition, taken from social science: a person’s identity as the picture they hold of themselves, joining who they were to who they hope to become.
He offers no further explanation, so what follows is only a reading. A fence is where one plot stops and the next begins. It is the simplest statement of identity a piece of land can make: this side is mine, that side is not. Hanging an equation there puts the two meanings of the word on the same wire. One is exact and permanent. The other is a line somebody drew and has to keep maintaining, while the brambles work on it from both directions.
The equation will hold forever. The wood it is written in will not.
That contrast is the quiet joke of the piece. Mathematicians admire Euler’s identity for being untouched by time and place, and here it is given a material that weathers, on a support that sags, in a garden that is slowly taking it back. The same instinct runs through Kenneth Snelson’s Needle Tower, where the balance of tension and compression is left outdoors to prove itself in the wind, and through Albert Chamillard’s ledger drawings, where perfect solids are built from thousands of imperfect pen strokes.
The artist
Aldo Tolino
Tolino was born in 1979 in Lilienfeld, Austria, and works in Vienna. His practice moves between photography, folded and cut paper, sculpture and digital processes, and keeps returning to one question: where does an image end and the thing carrying it begin? Identität fits that concern neatly. The work exists as a series of three fine art pigment prints sealed under acrylic glass, each about 80 × 100 cm, in an edition of seven with two artist’s proofs. What collectors hang is a picture of an equation on a fence, one step further removed from the garden where it stood.